M.İ. and her family are seeking justice. In 2019, she was sexually abused over a period of four months by more than 40 men, according to her account of the number of accused. The principal suspects also forced her to meet other men. She became pregnant as a result of the abuse and underwent an abortion.

All defendants in the file were released.

In 2002, 14-year-old N.Ç. was sexually abused by 28 people, deprived of her liberty and confined.

After N.Ç. filed a complaint with prosecutors, 27 of the 28 suspects were arrested. The trial lasted eleven years. Her statements were taken without specialist support, and relatives of the defendants attacked her after hearings.

As a result, the crimes of "deprivation of liberty" and "encouragement of prostitution" against the defendants were time-barred and they were not punished for these crimes.

The European Court of Human Rights found that the fact that the trial was not conducted diligently was contrary to the "obligation to protect the child victim of abuse" and ruled that the child was exposed to secondary victimization and ruled that Articles 3 (prohibition of torture and ill-treatment) and 8 (right to respect for private life) of the ECHR were violated.

Another file similar to N.Ç.'s file is currently in the Court of Appeal. The family is waiting for a fair decision, but they are not hopeful.

'HE FOUND SOMEONE FOR ME, AND THOSE PEOPLE WERE RAPING ME'

The news you will read is the story of M.İ., who was 15 years old when she was subjected to abuse.

The beginning of the crime of abuse dates back to 2019 and before. A.G., one of the main defendants in the file and a distant relative of M.İ. The person named started spending time around the school that M.İ. attended, and M.İ. He tries to communicate with M.İ. and one day he goes to M.İ.

M.İ. In the case file he explains:

"My mother invites you home, can you come to our house?" she said. Then we went to their house, and as soon as we entered the door, he suddenly took out a knife. He held a knife to my throat. He said, "If you don't do what I say, I will kill you," and then he raped me. He kept coming around the school. During that time, he was constantly threatening. He took a video with another phone, showed it to me and said 'come with me'. "At that time, they were finding people for me, and those people were raping me."

A.G., who exploited M.İ. After a while, he forcibly detains the child so that M.İ. can be abused by other men, takes him to other men and starts threatening him with blackmail.

M.I. About this process, he says, "He was constantly threatening me by showing the video on his phone. He was constantly finding people for me."

THE CHILD'S STATEMENT WAS TAKEN WITHOUT EXPERT OFFICIALS

M.I. Due to the abuse she was subjected to, she becomes pregnant and is subjected to an abortion. In this process, he tells the defendants to his family, and then the family files a complaint with the prosecutor's office. Before his statement was taken, M.İ. He is not allowed to see a psychologist. M.İ.'s statement is taken without the presence of experts and pedagogues in the room as required by the Child Protection Law, and it is recorded in this way.

M.İ., A.K., M.O.K., H.Ö. mentioned in the file. and A.G. A lawsuit is being filed against the defendants named in the criminal court of first instance on charges of "Sexual abuse, Encouraging Children to Engage in Prostitution, Producing or Intermediating Prostitution, Depriving the Person of Liberty by Using Coercive Threats or Cheating".

In one of the first hearings of the case, the judge asks the abused child to tell again what he experienced and asks what happened in the video in which he was blackmailed.

15-year-old M.İ., who was subjected to qualified sexual abuse by many men for months. replies:

"They were raping both themselves and the people who came. The video showed him raping me."

The judge also asks the child whether he remembers where the crime of abuse usually took place and the number of defendants.

15-year-old M.İ., who was subjected to qualified sexual abuse by many men for months. replies:

"We usually went to TOKİ with the people they brought, to the deserted places of our village. In my previous statement, I said 40 people or so, but I'm not sure if it was more."

JUDGE TO CHILD: “Did you say you did not want to be abused?”

In Turkey, where more than 50 thousand child sexual abuse cases are filed every year, the judge in this case asks whether the child "told them that he did not want this" while the defendants were committing the crime of abuse.

15-year-old M.İ., who was subjected to qualified sexual abuse by many men for months. replies:

"I was telling them, but they were showing violence."

THE LOCAL COURT DECISIONS TO ACQUIT ALL DEFENDANTS

The decision day of the case is coming and the local court stated that "...the victim was over fifteen years old on the date of the crime in 2019, the victim stated in his police statement that he had sexual intercourse more than once based on his legally valid consent at different times but did not complain, and that the prosecution of the crime of "Sexual Intercourse with a Minor", which is alleged to have occurred as a result of the actions carried out against the victim who was over fifteen years old on the date of the crime in 2019, depends on the complaint..."; It decides to acquit the defendants of the crime of "kidnapping and detaining a child" and to drop them from the file of the crime of "sexual intercourse with a minor" on the grounds that "the child gave consent and did not complain."

Therefore, in this file, with the statement "on the grounds" that a girl was over 15 years old at the time she was subjected to abuse and that "she has consent"; Instead of abuse, the defendants are acquitted by saying "he had sexual intercourse" and by not taking into account the fact that he withdrew his complaint under threat.

'PUT ME IN THE PLACE OF YOUR OWN DAUGHTERS'

The family takes the file to the Court of Appeal and in the petition of objection against the decision, M.İ. He uses the following statements towards the court:

"If everything happened with my consent and I did not really file a complaint with my free will, why did I receive psychological treatment for years during and after the incident? Like every child, I was shy and scared. I was subjected to sexual abuse by countless men. All the defendants committed qualified sexual abuse against me with threats and forced me into prostitution in the same way; as a result of this pressure, they exposed me to sexual intercourse with 40-50 people in exchange for money. When you are only 14 years old, you fall among many wild men and "You are all alone. You cannot tell anyone anything. At that age, put me in the place of your daughters."

'MY DAUGHTER WAS ABUSED BY MORE THAN FORTY PEOPLE'

The family and the family's lawyer want the acquittal decision to be overturned and the defendants to be caught and tried in detention. The family's lawyer states that this case should be heard directly in the high criminal court and that he finds it unlawful to acquit all the defendants because the child was forced to withdraw his complaint by blackmail.

The father, who is fighting for justice for his child, stated that his child withdrew his complaint under threat and said, "They tell my child, 'We know where your brother is studying, we see it. We will kidnap him too, we will do the same to him. Let's kill you, you are already pregnant." If they were tried properly, they would be sentenced to 50 years in prison. They got my 15-year-old child pregnant. This child is under 18!” He shows his reaction to the decision by using the following expressions.

The father also wants the case to be overturned and the defendants to be given a fair retrial:

“We object to the case, Türkiye is not a state of law. "My daughter was abused by more than forty people for 4 months."

'THE CHILD'S STATEMENT WAS TAKEN IN CONTRADICTION WITH THE PROVISIONS OF CMK'

Speaking to 12punto about the file, Lawyer Fırat Çiçek from the Istanbul Bar Association Children's Rights Center underlines that it is a legal obligation for the statements of children who are victims of abuse to be taken by experts:

“The Code of Criminal Procedure, to which the prosecutor's office handling the file and the local court are subject, clearly states that the testimony of the child victim of abuse should be taken in a private environment through experts. The statement of the child victim of abuse was taken at the police station, contrary to the provisions of the Criminal Code. "And the court deemed the statements in a legally invalid statement valid and gave a 'dismissal' decision to the defendants regarding the child abuse that has become systematic in the provinces."

'THE EXPRESSION "CONSENT" DOES NOT APPLY IN TCK ARTICLES 103 AND 104.'

Making statements about the concept of "consent", which is put forward for sexual abuse crimes committed against children and which is incompatible with the principle of the best interest of the child, Çiçek draws attention to the "construction of consent" and adds:

"The expression "consent" is not included in articles 103 and 104 of the Turkish Penal Code regarding acts of sexual violence against children. Here, the legislator used the expression "force, threat, fraud or another reason affecting the will" instead of the expression "consent" of the child. In other words, in the child's statement "I have consent", an investigation of "force, threat, fraud or another reason affecting the will" must be carried out on the way to establishing consent. Likewise, in our case, the victim child was systematically threatened and blackmailed. "The trial should have been carried out by the prosecutor's office and the local court by carefully detecting a fraudulent tool that put the victim in a position that would not allow him to resist the actions in question."

Editor's note: Due to the best interests of the child, the names of the child and his family, details of the place where the crime was committed, and the names of the defendants mentioned in the file have been kept confidential in this news.

Striking statistical data of sexual abuse crimes against children in Türkiye are shared below. According to TÜİK statistics, 22 thousand girls and 3,626 boys became victims of sexual crimes in 2023.

More than 66 thousand child sexual abuse files were opened in 2023 alone.

14,919 child sexual abuse cases were heard in the courts. 7 thousand 88 people were convicted.

More than 10 thousand girls were forced into marriage in 2023 alone.

In 2023, 130 children under the age of 15 gave birth. In the 15-17 age group, 6,505 children gave birth.

At least 14 girls were killed in the first 7 months of 2024.

Share
XLinkedInWhatsApp