In the case where Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu was tried with the demand of 'imprisonment' and 'political ban' on the grounds that he insulted the chairman and members of the YSK in the press statement he made after the cancellation of the March 31 elections, the court sentenced İmamoğlu to 2 years, 7 months and 15 days in prison. On the other hand, there was a political ban according to Article 53 of the Turkish Penal Code.

In order for the decision to be finalized, the appellate court and Supreme Court processes must be completed.

17.50: The court sentenced İmamoğlu to 2 years, 7 months and 15 days in prison and a political ban according to Article 53 of the Turkish Penal Code.

17.45 Support from Nermin Abadan Unat to İmamoğlu...

101-year-old Nermin Abadan Unat, one of the names who have the biggest share in the development of communication sciences in Türkiye, came to the town hall in Saraçhane to support IMM President Ekrem İmamoğlu.

17.30: The president of the court said 'the trial has ended'. There was a 30-minute break to decide.

17.25: Lawyer Kemal Polat said, "We have never been asked to postpone the announcement of the verdict until this case. I hope this is not something like giving a sentence of 2 years and 2 months. I am ending my defense here. I want this attitude to be recorded as a protest.

17.00: Lawyer Gökhan Günaydın said, "Judges make decisions, you said that all of our opinions are aimed at prolonging the case. An opinion was given in the fourth session of this hearing. Same as the indictment. We brought witnesses. They clearly stated to whom the words were spoken. We do not accept the granting of 3 hours of time in such a critical case, even though the defense says they are not ready. We are here to make the final decision, saying we trust the Turkish judicial system. Ekrem İmamoğlu responded to Süleyman Soylu, criticized him and made an evaluation regarding this. His words are not directed at YSK members. Not only Türkiye but the whole world witnessed what happened on election night. Has a lawsuit been filed against Süleyman Soylu, who called the elected president Ekrem İmamoğlu a fool? We answer. No. Has a lawsuit been filed ex officio? No. It is the duty of public prosecutors. YSK members have not made any complaints or requests to participate in the case on this issue.

Five days after the speech of IMM President Mr. Ekrem İmamoğlu, the content and purpose of which are stated above, Minister of Internal Affairs Süleyman Soylu made a statement on November 4, 2019 and criticized the Client for his speech at the Congress; "I say to the fool who goes to the European Parliament and complains about Türkiye; this nation will make you pay for this. Shame on you," he said.

As can be clearly understood from here, the person Soylu is trying to brand by saying "the fool who complains about Turkey" is Ekrem İmamoğlu. In other words, the person who first used the word "idiot" and directed it to an elected mayor was Süleyman Soylu.

Representatives of the political power and the People's Alliance consider it their right to inflict all kinds of humiliation and insults on various segments of society. They make all kinds of insults against people's ethnic origins, cultural identities, beliefs and gender. They can make all kinds of threats, blackmail and insults against state institutions, professional chambers and civil society. However, they are not subjected to any questioning or punishment. The judiciary remains blind and deaf to the government's heavy insults and unfounded accusations against citizens, professional chambers and all state institutions, including the constitutional court.

Names at the top of the government, such as Erdoğan, Bahçeli and Soylu, under the armor and protection of the judiciary, prefer to antagonize their biggest rivals, whom they can talk to on democratic grounds, by coding the Nation Alliance, which represents the majority of opposition politicians and voters, as "a disgrace and disgrace". In the oppressive climate created by this hostility-based hegemony, the government aims to subjugate all segments of the population, from the opposition to civil society, from professional chambers to students.

We have to quote here some of the words of AKP Chairman Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, in his speeches at his party's group meetings, openings and rallies, towards opposition party leaders and those who criticize the government, in the context of the crime of insult, which is the subject of the case; 'Damn immoral people', 'scoundrels', 'immoral', 'without offspring', 'dung', 'mud', 'blockhead', 'scoundrel', 'excuse me, Armenian', 'dishonorable', 'immoral', 'slick', 'idiot', 'vampire', 'renegade', 'virus', 'degenerate', 'disgrace', 'jackal', 'dead' lover', 'bad manners', 'spawn of Israel'.

He alienates Erdoğan and Bahçeli Kılıçdaroğlu through his Alevi identity and turns them into enemies. Erdoğan marginalizes the leader of the CHP, whom he calls "dung", based on his identity by saying "you know, Alevi". Erdoğan deepens his discriminatory attitude by saying "the liar's candle burns until nightfall, but it has nothing to do with nighttime" about Kılıçdaroğlu. Bahçeli refers to his identity by saying "we are sending you a lamp, light the lamp, put on the cone, enjoy yourself" for Kılıçdaroğlu, who did not pay the electricity bill. Süleyman Soylu may describe Kılıçdaroğlu as "the main opposition leader who travels from one corner to another". Again, while no action was taken against Soylu Kılıçdaroğlu for using the phrase "it looks like a plastic show, it morphs into different shapes, it looks like a space creature", an indictment is being prepared against the citizen who commented on these words about Soylu "looking into the mirror and talking".

We have to quote some of the insults made by the Minister of Internal Affairs Süleyman Soylu, who submitted a complaint to the Court on the grounds that he was insulted, in his speeches and social media accounts, again in terms of the subject of the case;

To CHP Chairman Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu; 'Could a rude, ugly, dishonest, deceitful, liar, dishonorable, despicable person have lived in space? It looks like a space creature.'

On September 3, 2019, to IMM President Ekrem İmamoğlu; "Know your limits, do your job, but if you deal with other things besides doing your job, we will be miserable." Then, he directs the word "idiot", which was the subject of the lawsuit on November 4, 2019, directly to Mr. Ekrem İmamoğlu.

To Canan Kaftancıoğlu, 'The clown of terrorist organizations.'

To Victory Party Chairman Ümit Özdağ; 'I don't consider this man a human being. This is a man lower than an animal. 'He is a Soros child and an operation child.'

To TİP Deputy Barış Atay; 'You would make the perfect rapist'

To journalist Müyesser Yıldız; 'Terror lover'

AKP Deputy Hakan Çavuşoğlu can easily say "despicable" about İmamoğlu. MHP Deputy Chairman Semih Yalçın can say about Akşener, "The girl who ran away from home is doing a trick, acting like a Phosphorescent Cevriye". The actions of these names who pollute the language of politics are not new. These people had insulted each other in the past as well. While Erdoğan was calling Bahçeli "without offspring, he doesn't know what family is", Bahçeli was calling Erdoğan "dishonorable", "Iblis" and "scoundrel".

Has any action been taken against the words of AKP Mersin Deputy Zeynep Gül Yılmaz towards the police officers who were checking the license plate in Mersin/Erdemli, "Look at the rude, dishonorable"?

Likewise, is there an investigation or prosecution opened against AKP Bursa Deputy Hakan Çavuşoğlu's insults against CHP Group Deputy Chairman Özgür Özel as "Oh, you bastard" and Istanbul Büyküşehir Municipality Ekrem İmamoğlu as "Scoundrel"?

These people who rule Turkey see themselves as having the right to insult and humiliate people from all groups living in Turkey, and they have put this under judicial protection. This dominating and hostile approach is not limited to politics. It also extends to government institutions, civil society, professional chambers and citizens. This injustice has spread to all areas of society. This state of affairs deeply shakes trust in both social life, institutions and justice.

So much so that Bahçeli compared the members of the Constitutional Court, the highest institution of the judiciary, with traitors. "The Constitutional Court has become such that wherever there is a traitor or a looter active to undermine Turkey, it is side by side with them." While no investigation has even been launched against Bahçeli, who used the statement, İmamoğlu, who recanted his words to Soylu who insulted him, is being tried for allegedly insulting all YSK members.

There is only one truth to this case. Süleyman Soylu insulted İmamoğlu, and İmamoğlu responded to him. However, ignoring this fact and trying to ban İmamoğlu from politics has no meaning other than sacrificing the judiciary to politics.

This case is not a case in which İmamoğlu is tried, but a case in which trust in justice is tested. The judiciary made a mistake and canceled the March 31 elections. Citizens responded to this judicial decision, which was made under the shadow of politics, on June 23. Trust in justice was tested and lost at the first mistake. Now, the responsibility of the judiciary is to learn the lesson from the first test and establish trust in justice. The judiciary has the duty to deliver the truth, not to change the truth.

There is a reality known and expressed by experienced judges, prosecutors, lawyers, in short, members of the judiciary who have bleached their hair in the courthouse corridors and have seen a lot about the relationship between law and politics: The judge follows the file until the decision is made, and the file follows the judge after the decision.

We all have duties and responsibilities regarding ourselves, our children and the future of our country. It is a wish on behalf of our country, not on our own behalf, that this scope be reflected in the decision of your court.

In this context, we request that the trial carried out on false, unfounded, and unfounded criminal charges be terminated and that our client be acquitted.

16.49: Lawyer Turan Taşkın Özer said, "My client's right to a fair trial has been damaged. When the words in question are considered as a whole, it is clearly stated in our professors' report that the material and moral elements of the crime of insult have not been formed. All opinions show that the crime has not occurred. When we prolong the trial, we get nothing. If we wanted to prolong the case, all the lawyers could withdraw from the case. I demand that the court act with its conscience and make a fair decision.

16.35: After the registration started with SEGBİS, the defense started. Lawyer Sercan Polat said, "We are defending against the opinion without sufficient time. In the opinion of the prosecutor, public officials were insulted in the indictment. There are consistent statements from three witnesses. It is clear that these words were spoken to Süleyman Soylu. "I request the acquittal of my client," he said.

16.20: Lawyer Polat's SEBGİS request was accepted. The court will be recorded both audio and video.

16.10: The court panel took its place after the break. The president of the court asked İmamoğlu's lawyers for their defense against the opinion.

Before his defense on the merits against the opinion, Kemal Polat said, "We declare all our written and verbal statements we have made up to this stage. I would like to present the issues regarding who the people who canceled the election are. This first one is the article of Abdulkadir Selvi within AKP on 08/04/2019. Minister Soylu, whose election was annulled, has evidence of will, and there is a crime. "I am presenting the letter that the election should be renewed," he said. Polat stated that they would make a long defense from the court and requested that it be recorded with SEGBİS.

SUPPORT FROM AKŞENER

14.29: İYİ Party leader Meral Akşener shared her support on her social media account. Akşener said, "I set out from Ankara, see you in Saraçhane."

14.21: CHP Deputy Chairman Muharrem Erkek quoted İmamoğlu's tweet and said, "This is a struggle for democracy... We will be in Saraçhane starting from 16.00."

14. 17: CHP Istanbul Provincial Chair Canan Kaftancıoğlu said in her message, "While we are watching the hearing in the hall at 16.00, we are waiting for our organization and the people of Istanbul to come to Şaraçhane at the same time."

In addition to the prison sentence, the prosecutor also wants the 53rd article of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK), which includes 'political ban', to be imposed on İmamoğlu.

13.47: In his post on his social media account, the Mayor of Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality made a call to Saraçhane. In his post, İmamoğlu said, "The home of 16 million Istanbulites is Saraçhane. Istanbul and Turkey will claim their will today, just as they did before. Whatever the decision is, I invite everyone to Saraçhane at 16.00 to show either our joy or our will."

"THEY DON'T DARE TO CALL SOYLU"

13.15: Making a statement after the decision to take a break, CHP Deputy Chairman Muharrem Erkek said, "A very important legal opinion was presented. The lawyers asked for time to give their last defense in writing and in detail, but the court gave time until 16.00."

Regarding the court's rejection of Soylu's request to be heard, Erkek said, "I think they do not dare to call the Minister of Internal Affairs, Süleyman Soylu, to the court. What have the rulers of this country done to the country? Those who rule the state have refuted justice. The people will answer for these injustices in the first election."

"IT LIKE THE DECISION WILL BE MADE TODAY"

13.10: CHP Istanbul Provincial Chair Canan Kaftancıoğlu, in her post on her social media account after the break, said, "For now, it seems that the decision in the Fool Case will be made today, despite the objections of his lawyers."

13.07: The court stated that an opinion on the merits was given in the previous two hearings, and that there was sufficient time to prepare the defense on the merits and against the opinion on the merits.

The court rejected the lawyers' request for time to submit their opinions. The hearing was adjourned until 16:00 for final arguments.

13.05: Speaking, lawyer Gökhan Günaydın said, "We listened to witness statements regarding the essence of the case. We received an important opinion from the commission that carried out the preparation of the TCK. It is diametrically opposed to the opinion of the prosecutor's office. For the right to a fair trial and the right to defense, it must be evaluated within a reasonable time and a written defense must be prepared. We request time on these issues."

12.59: The Public Prosecutor took the floor and repeated his opinion from the previous hearing in which he demanded that the defendant İmamoğlu be punished with imprisonment of up to 4 years and 1 month for the crime of "publicly insulting public officials working as a committee due to their duties" and asked for a political ban.

12.55: The presiding judge rejected the requests to hear witnesses, stating that the reports should be detailed and understandable and that there was no need to hear the people who prepared these reports again. He decided to reject the request, stating that hearing Minister of Internal Affairs Süleyman Soylu would not benefit the case. He also rejected the defendant's lawyers' request for time to make a written statement, stating that it was to prolong the case.

12.45: Lawyer Gökhan Günaydın: "Süleyman Soylu should be heard here. We also want our request to be heard as an expert witness to be accepted."

12.40: Lawyer Kemal Polat said after the video, "This is exactly why I want it to be heard. It involves manipulation here. We did not file a lawsuit against him. Our client is a public official. If this is an insult against the person who called the public official a fool, the prosecutor's office should take action ex officio."

12.35: A video containing Minister of Internal Affairs Süleyman Soylu's speech regarding the case was shown in the courtroom.

12.30: Kemal Polat requested that the expert witnesses in the report they submitted be heard.

12.25: İmamoğlu's lawyers received opinions from three law professors and presented them to the court. The judge read the opinions in question at this hearing.

12.20: İmamoğlu's lawyer, Kemal Polat, requested time to make a written statement regarding the witness statements. On the other hand, Polat requested that the CD they submitted to the file be analyzed and added to the file.

Necati Özkan: "I accompany Mr. Ekrem to all the meetings he goes to. This was the case in the meeting in Strasbourg. After the elections of March 31 and June 23, a foreign delegation that came to Türkiye upon the request of the Government of the Republic of Turkey observed the elections and wrote a report. After all the elections in Europe, the European Parliament operates a similar mechanism. A delegation in the European Parliament reports the anomalies seen in the elections to the parliament. Not only Ekrem İmamoğlu, but also Kocaeli, A delegation of 14 people, including various mayors from Izmir, was invited to discuss the report in Strasbourg. We went early that morning and returned the same evening, 5 days after our return, we were at a meeting with the mayor in Üsküdar.

We learned about Soylu's inappropriate words. When asked by journalists, he returned the criticism by pointing directly to the address and saying, "I look at the man, or do I look at the words?" The next day, the headlines in all newspapers were "Ekrem İmamoğlu responded to Soylu". That's how the press understood it. Mr. Ekrem acted like this. We didn't understand how this happened.

The Minister of Internal Affairs also told the public that he cried when he learned that Binali Yıldırım had lost for the second time on the election night. The Minister of Internal Affairs forgets that the power he wields is power on behalf of the public and then acts like a soldier of the party he belongs to. "He made many actions, statements and insults targeting Ekrem İmamoğlu from the beginning to the end of this case."

11.55: İmamoğlu's campaign director Necati Özkan is being heard as a witness.

Murat Ongun: "Friends of the press sent a message to the President of the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality that he called the President of the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality an idiot in the press statement of the Minister of Internal Affairs Süleyman Soylu. They asked him if he wanted to respond to this issue. I also asked our president about the issue. In our conversation with him, I said, 'He called you an idiot.' He said, 'This is an inappropriate expression, let's respond to him.' I also invited my journalist friends. In his response, our president said, 'I will listen to the words.' "I said, Mr. President, 'I wonder if it was too heavy,' and he said, 'It was even a little.'"

11.50: The court decided to hear witnesses. Murat Ongun is heard first as a witness at the hearing.

11.45: İmamoğlu's lawyer Kemal Polat said, "We do not accept the postponement of the announcement of the verdict. When we look at the legal opinion we have previously presented, Durmuş Tezcan, who serves in the Criminal Law Commission of the Ministry of Justice and represents our country before the ECHR, Assoc. Prof. Dr. who serves in the Criminal Law Commission of the Ministry of Justice. Murat Önok and Assoc. Prof. An expert opinion was given by Hasan Sınar. "We submitted a new opinion by 3 experts and we request that it be evaluated," he said.

11.30: Many MPs are watching the case. İmamoğlu's lawyers' request for a recusal judge at the previous hearing was rejected.

11.00: District heads, lawyers and many journalists were not allowed into the Istanbul Anatolian Courthouse 7th Criminal Court of First Instance, where the case will be heard.

10.45: Entrance to the Anatolian Courthouse, where the case filed against Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality (IMM) Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu for allegedly insulting the members of the Supreme Electoral Board (YSK) is being heard, has been restricted.

Entrance to the Istanbul Anatolian Courthouse, where the trial of Ekrem İmamoğlu will be heard, has been restricted. pic.twitter.com/7LNlL582dm — Metropolitan Works (@tcbuyuksehir) December 14, 2022

Share
XLinkedInWhatsApp